After spending eight days on the Carnival Miracle with world class dinners and room care, I may be a little tainted but please read on.
Today is our 10th day of travels afield and our second day in Orlando Florida. Saturday started crystal clear with a high of 72F, so the weather is not adding to my negative position (unlike last night). We had an opportunity to drive around town, hit a very large Flea Market, a mall and comic book store that I use to frequent when I was in the Navy. And yes, she bought me a Cylon Toaster shirt (she knew what it was and what show it was referenced in, my doll is a geek).
Back to the hotel.
We chose to just stay at a cheap place so we could putter around town while waiting to check-in at Disney. Following my normal approach, I went to hotels.com and searched based on location and sorted by price and rating. After reading some reviews and looking at the available photos of the hotel, I chose one that I thought was a great value (meaning, cheap and rated high). Well, as I stated above, my tweet last night says it all.
My biggest problem is that the people who obviously fill out the reviews are either use to a lower standard than I am or they lack a complete grasp on reality. The average rating is a 3.1 (out of 5.0) for a two star hotel is pretty normal compared to hotels in the area (average of 3.8).
Now where the review falls on its face:
- There is no wireless internet in the room (only in the hotel lobby, next to the desk)
- If that’s satellite TV, they need to consider upgrading to one that circles the planet, since the picture quality looked like they were jacking it from the neighboring hotel.
- There was indeed a safe in the room, but someone had long ago drilled out the lock and damaged it beyond use. Not sure if you should be marketing the room with that feature.
- I love the “Accessibility equipment for the Deaf” statement, since due to the high level of 24×7 traffic on I-Drive and the proximity to that street, it sounded like we were sleeping in the kitchen of a 24 hour drive-in taco bell. Only the deaf would enjoy this room.
Now what these reviews are lacking for consistency:
- Cleanliness: Poor, there was dust, grime and mildew in every openly accessible corner. The wife won’t take her shoes off to come to bed.
- Smell: The mildew had mildew, and the air conditioner took 20 minutes to turn on
- Equipment: There was a refrigerator (yeah), which had only three legs and leaned forward so the door couldn’t open (boo). And, it didn’t work.
- General Appearance: Stains on lampshades, paint peeling on the ceiling and damage to the door like someone took a crowbar to gain access when they lost their card key.
- Age: Somewhere in the 70′s mixed with 90′s Spanish east-side.
We rate this about a 1.2 and hope to never stay here again (of course, that excludes tonight.)
PS: Before someone takes this information and applies a little social engineering in order to get our address and try to rob us, I should add we left our adult children (one gun-toting boyfriend and one Aunt) to administer our home; with our two attack dogs.
PPS: The wife reminded me, “you get what you pay for,” which doesn’t mean I should stop whining!

Hi John & Lisa, We stayed in a pit in Santa Fe last summer. I think the year of the motel/hotel should be asked when making reservations. We stayed on night and moved the next morning. Thank goodness you are moving to another place. Have a great time at Disney!
yeah, good thing you only have to stay one night, then DISNEY!
And as I enjoy my Disney room, I can tell you, not a dust bunny, mildew streak or smelly item in the room. Night and day folks, night and day. Funny what an extra $100 will get ya.
I am just now checking on you and got a real kick out of your motel stay. Been there, done that! I agree that the extra $100 may be worth it. Hope you are having fun!
[...] what Orlando had to hold for us. One of two blog postings I did while on sabbatical was about the poor quality of the hotel we stayed in during our two days prior to Disney. We gave the opportunity for all the kids to fly [...]
I am a cheap guy, but still expect a level of service no matter where I go.